Thinker's Chronicle

The Vatican Summit

As the world changes and different marginalized groups become more and more outspoken, others must discuss how these changes affect them and how they can be more receptive. An example of this is the month-long summit, called the Synod of Bishops, organized by Pope Francis to discuss a series of 151 proposals.

While many were hoping for a more open and clear example of progress, the summit ended with a call for more female involvement in the church but did not allow for women to serve as deacons (a minister ranking below that of a priest). The consultation combined 368 people; however, it is important to note that the pope had opened up the conference to some lay people, or not ordained people, including around 60 women.

Photo Credits: USNews

Although the summit did not push forward to open up the position of deacon to women, it has noted that “there is no reason or impediment that should prevent women from carrying out leadership roles in the Church”. A ⅔ majority was required to pass each of the 151 proposals set before the summit members; while all proposals passed, the one closest to failing was the proposal set to giving women more leadership opportunities within the church. It received 258-97 votes. 

Furthermore, the summit was a chance for proponents of the LGBTQ+  community to advocate for better ways to welcome those often spurned minority members. However, the final text had only a few lines about those who felt “excluded” due to their “marital status, identity or sexuality”. Even though many were disappointed about the lack of progress in this area, others were impressed by the push to get even this far due to the substantial traditionalist opposition.

Despite the fact that the conference did not end in a satisfactory way for some, Pope Francis continues looking for solutions. This can be seen when he assigned groups to study and report back to him by June about whether women can be ordained as deacons. Another important aspect of the pope’s views is his interest in the perspective of “grassroots” Catholics (not just those who are ordained), as highlighted by this conference.

While the summit did not have the great push for progress which many had hoped for, its very existence showcases the movement towards a more equal future for the church. 

Mihika Rajeev